If you’re considering revamping your room with a fresh coat of paint, choosing the right color is crucial. Today, I want to talk about SW 0023 Pewter Tankard by Sherwin Williams, a shade that’s been on my radar as I look for the perfect color to refresh my home. This particular gray hue offers a balance between refined and cozy, making it flexible for different rooms.
What stands out about Pewter Tankard is its ability to adjust. Whether you aim for a contemporary look or something more traditional, this color has the potential to fit smoothly into your design scheme.
Before you decide, let me share a few insights about its undertones, how it reacts to different lighting conditions, and what color pairings enhance its unique beauty.
This groundwork will help ensure that you make a choice you’ll be happy with for years to come.

Is Pewter Tankard SW 0023 Right for My Home?
As someone who loves decorating and finding the perfect shades for every room, I must say Pewter Tankard by Sherwin Williams is a fantastic choice for those looking to add a subtle yet impactful tone to their room. This color is a deep, warm gray that strikes a beautiful balance between bold and soothing. Its richness makes it flexible for various interior styles, particularly modern, industrial, and traditional décors.
I’ve found that Pewter Tankard pairs exceptionally well with natural materials and textures. In a room with hardwood floors or wooden furniture, this shade adds a layer of warmth and depth. When combined with metal accents or fixtures, it creates a pleasing contrast that really makes the elements pop. It’s also great with softer textures like wool or linen, adding a cozy feel to any room.
In my own home, I’ve used Pewter Tankard in the living room where it works beautifully against my leather sofa and metal light fixtures, creating a welcoming yet stylish room. Its classic quality ensures it blends seamlessly with almost any décor style, making it a go-to paint color for anyone looking to refresh their home.

What are the right undertones of Pewter Tankard SW 0023 ?
Pewter Tankard is a flexible shade characterized by a complex blend of undertones that influence how it is perceived in different lighting conditions and environments. Undertones are subtle hues that surface from the main color under certain lighting conditions, affecting how the color feels and coordinates with other palettes.
With undertones like pale pink, mint, and pale yellow, Pewter Tankard can appear slightly warmer, invoking a cozy and welcoming feel. These lighter undertones help brighten up rooms, making the area feel more open and less constricted. On the other hand, the presence of darker undertones like olive, orange, and brown lends a grounding effect, giving the color a richer depth that works well in study areas or libraries where a touch of formality is desired.
When used on interior walls, the diversity of Pewter Tankard’s undertones can cause the color to appear differently based on the room’s exposure to natural light or the type of artificial lighting used. For instance, in a room with plenty of natural light, the lighter undertones like light blue and lilac might become more pronounced, creating a lively and airy atmosphere. Conversely, in a room with less light, darker undertones like navy and dark green might stand out, making the room feel more enclosed and intimate.
Thus, the mix of undertones in Pewter Tankard adds complexity and flexibility, enabling it to blend smoothly with various decor styles and color schemes. This makes it a practical choice for those wishing to paint their interior walls with a color that can easily adjust to changing decor or varying amounts of light.

Best Coordinating Colors to use with Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams this year.
Coordinating colors are shades that complement a primary color, enhancing the overall aesthetic of a room without feeling too strong. When working with a neutral base like Pewter Tankard by Sherwin Williams, choosing the right coordinating colors is crucial for achieving a balanced look. Coordinating colors harmonize with the main hue, either by sharing similar undertones or by offering a pleasing contrast that highlights the beauty of the primary color.
For instance, Westhighland White by Sherwin Williams acts as a perfect coordinating color for Pewter Tankard. It’s a warm and soft white that brings a sense of cleanliness and brightness to the room, allowing the richer tones of Pewter Tankard to stand out without clashing. This color is ideal for trim, ceilings, or even as an accent wall if you’re looking to create a subtle yet refreshing look.
On the other hand, Lite Lavender offers a gentle pop of color. This light purple hue has a calm and gentle feel, providing a slight contrast to Pewter Tankard’s deeper tones which helps in making the room feel more dynamic and engaging. Lite Lavender works well in bedrooms or bathrooms, offering a light, airy presence that softens the overall decor.
You can see recommended paint colors below:

Trendy Trim Colors of Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams to use this year.
Trim colors, like the accents on a painting’s frame, enhance and define the overall appearance of a wall painted with a main color. In the case of using a distinctive shade like Pewter Tankard by Sherwin Williams, choosing the right trim colors is crucial as it can enhance the pewter shade’s richness and depth without feeling too strong. Trim colors should complement the wall color to create a cohesive look that feels intentional and polished.
For Pewter Tankard, using a trim color like Balanced Beige (SW 7037) offers a subtle contrast that highlights the neutral undertones of the pewter, giving the room a more defined and finished appearance.
Balanced Beige is a warm, inviting color that gently outlines Pewter Tankard, ensuring the room feels welcoming and put together. Alternatively, Mushroom (SW 9587) provides a slightly darker, earthier contrast to the cooler tones of the pewter color, adding an element of natural charm. This color is warm and flexible, creating a soothing border that ties the room’s elements together beautifully.
You can see recommended paint colors below:

Evergreen Colors Similar to Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams
Choosing similar colors for a room is important because it ensures a cohesive and harmonious look. Using colors like Pewter Tankard and its various similar shades creates a smooth visual flow in any room, making it feel more put together. Colors that are alike generally share a base tone but have different saturations or lightness, allowing for subtle contrasts that keep interiors interesting without feeling too intense.
For example, Smooth Stone is a light, almost neutral gray that offers a fresh, clean look perfect for modern rooms. Pavestone, slightly darker, gives depth to an area while maintaining a calm ambiance. Fawn Brindle steps it up with a hint of warmer undertones, making it ideal for cozy, inviting environments.
Rushing River brings in a cooler tone, reminiscent of a cloudy sky, adding a touch of moodiness to the atmosphere. Western Reserve, with its subdued richness, offers a gentle shift toward more traditional aesthetics without being too bold. Acier, on the darker side, provides a strong anchor point in a room, perfect for accent walls. Intellectual Gray has a refined blend of gray with soft brown, making it flexible for both contemporary and traditional decors.
Mega Greige combines gray with a touch of beige, creating a perfect backdrop for a variety of decor styles. Functional Gray is excellent for those who prefer a straightforward, no-frills look, while Morris Room Grey rounds out the selection with its deep tone, grounding the environment with its strong presence. Together, these colors synchronize to enhance the aesthetics of a room subtly and effectively.
You can see recommended paint colors below:
- SW 9568 Smooth Stone (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7642 Pavestone (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7640 Fawn Brindle (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7746 Rushing River (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 9597 Western Reserve (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 9170 Acier (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7045 Intellectual Gray (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7031 Mega Greige (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 7024 Functional Gray (CHECK A SAMPLE)
- SW 0037 Morris Room Grey (CHECK A SAMPLE)

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Functional Gray SW 7024 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Functional Gray by Sherwin Williams are two neutral colors that bring different vibes to a room. Pewter Tankard is a deep gray with a hint of warmth, making it cozy and inviting.
It’s perfect for creating a comforting atmosphere in living rooms or bedrooms. On the other hand, Functional Gray is a lighter shade that leans more toward a classic gray. It offers a clean and straightforward look, making it ideal for modern rooms or as a background for displaying artwork and other decor elements.
While Pewter Tankard adds depth and warmth, Functional Gray provides a subtle brightness and a fresh feel. Both colors work well with various decor styles and can enhance the aesthetic of a home efficiently and beautifully.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Mega Greige SW 7031 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Mega Greige are two popular shades from Sherwin Williams. Pewter Tankard is a deeper gray with a hint of warmth, making it a cozy choice for rooms needing a subtle, yet impactful color.
It pairs beautifully with both bright and neutral palettes, adding a touch of elegance without feeling too intense. On the other hand, Mega Greige leans more toward a beige-gray, a lighter shade that brings a soft, inviting feel to any room. It’s flexible and works well in rooms that get a lot of natural light, enhancing the airy and open ambiance.
While both colors offer a neutral base, Pewter Tankard provides a bolder statement, whereas Mega Greige offers a softer, more subtle backdrop. These colors can work harmoniously together or separately, depending on the mood and style you want to achieve in your decorating project. Each brings its own unique flair to interiors, catering to different aesthetic preferences and design needs.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Pavestone SW 7642 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Pavestone, both by Sherwin Williams, offer distinct gray tones, each bringing its own unique vibe to a room. Pewter Tankard is a deeper gray with a noticeable warmth, making it cozy and inviting.
This color is perfect for creating a snug atmosphere in areas like living rooms or dens. On the other hand, Pavestone leans toward a cooler, lighter gray, providing a more neutral backdrop. It’s excellent for modern rooms as it gives a clean and fresh look, ideally suited for kitchens or bathrooms.
Both colors are flexible and work well in various lighting situations, though Pewter Tankard tends to make a stronger statement with its richer hue, while Pavestone offers more flexibility because of its understated elegance.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Intellectual Gray SW 7045 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard is a medium-dark gray with hints of blue and green, giving it a somewhat cooler tone. It is flexible and easily fits in various settings, providing a calm, neutral background that pairs well with both bright and muted accents.
On the other hand, Intellectual Gray is a lighter shade of gray compared to Pewter Tankard. It leans slightly toward a taupe-like gray with a warm undertone. This color is softer and lighter, making rooms feel more open and airy.
Both colors are great for creating a modern and clean look in a home. Pewter Tankard works well in areas where a stronger, more pronounced color is desired, while Intellectual Gray is ideal for rooms where a lighter, soothing gray is preferred. Each color offers a distinct mood and can beautifully complement a range of decorative styles and preferences.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Morris Room Grey SW 0037 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Morris Room Grey are two distinct shades offered by Sherwin Williams. Pewter Tankard has a deep, silvery-grey tone that brings to mind the color of aged metal, making it a solid choice for rooms aiming for a classic yet strong presence.
Its richness perfectly suits areas like living rooms or bedrooms where a cozy, inviting atmosphere is desired. On the other hand, Morris Room Grey is lighter and has a more neutral grey quality. This color is very flexible and works well in various settings, helping to create a clean and open feeling.
It’s especially suitable for smaller rooms or rooms that don’t get much natural light, as its lighter hue helps to make rooms appear larger and more airy. Both colors have their unique appeal and can be used effectively depending on the mood and style you want to achieve in your room.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Acier SW 9170 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Acier, both by Sherwin Williams, are unique shades of gray that have their distinct characteristics. Pewter Tankard is a warmer gray, infused with a hint of beige that gives it a cozy, inviting feel.
This color works well in living rooms or bedrooms where a soft, welcoming ambiance is desired. On the other hand, Acier presents a cooler tone, leaning more toward a steel gray. This color is excellent for creating a modern and clean look, perfect for rooms that aim for a more contemporary vibe, such as kitchens or offices.
Both colors are flexible and neutral, making them easy to pair with various decor styles and color palettes. While Pewter Tankard offers a gentle warmth, Acier provides a sharper, more defined presence, reflecting different moods and styles depending on the room’s purpose and lighting.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Rushing River SW 7746 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard is a shade of gray with warm undertones, making it a flexible and inviting choice for rooms where you want a cozy, yet neutral backdrop. This color is soft and subtle, providing an excellent base that can match with a wide range of decor styles without feeling too strong in the room.
On the other hand, Rushing River is a deeper gray that leans towards blue-green. This color is slightly more bold and distinct compared to Pewter Tankard. It has the ability to add depth and character to a room , making it a great option for creating a focal point in a room or giving a more dramatic look.
Both colors are quite neutral, but Rushing River introduces a touch of color that can generate a more dynamic visual effect, while Pewter Tankard remains more classic and understated. Using them together can create a nuanced interior that combines stability with a hint of flair.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Smooth Stone SW 9568 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Smooth Stone are both neutral colors from Sherwin Williams, but they have distinct tones that set them apart. Pewter Tankard is a deeper gray with a hint of warmth, making it a strong choice for rooms where you want a solid, grounding effect without going too dark. It works well in living areas and can be a great backdrop for both vibrant and muted furnishings.
On the other hand, Smooth Stone is lighter and carries a soft, airy feel. It’s an excellent option for smaller rooms or rooms that don’t get a lot of natural light, as it can help make the area feel brighter and more open. This color suits bedrooms and bathrooms well, where a calm and gentle environment is often desired.
Both colors offer flexibility and can complement various decor styles, but the choice between them depends largely on the mood you want to create and how much natural light your room receives.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Fawn Brindle SW 7640 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Fawn Brindle, both by Sherwin Williams, are neutral shades, each bringing their own unique vibe to rooms. Pewter Tankard is a deep, warm grey that has hints of silver, making it a solid choice for those looking to add a bit of a stronger, yet inviting feel to their rooms. It pairs well with bright whites or contrasting dark colors for a balanced look.
Fawn Brindle, on the other hand, is a lighter, softer grey with a touch of brown. This color offers a subtle warmth and is perfect for creating a cozy atmosphere without darkening the room too much. It’s fantastic for smaller rooms or areas with limited natural light as it doesn’t absorb as much light as deeper tones.
Both colors are flexible for various decorating styles, but Pewter Tankard leans toward a bolder, more dramatic look, while Fawn Brindle is suited for a lighter, airy feel. Depending on the mood you’re aiming to achieve, each color has its merits in enhancing the aesthetic of a home.
You can see recommended paint color below:

Pewter Tankard SW 0023 by Sherwin Williams vs Western Reserve SW 9597 by Sherwin Williams
Pewter Tankard and Western Reserve, both by Sherwin Williams, are distinct shades that can set very different moods in a room. Pewter Tankard is a deep gray with a hint of warmth. This color can make a room feel cozy and welcoming while still maintaining a touch of modern style. It works well in living areas and bedrooms where a calm, inviting atmosphere is desired.
On the other hand, Western Reserve is a darker, richer hue. It leans toward a blend of gray and green, recalling the natural colors of a forest. This makes it perfect for rooms where you want to create a grounding, more nature-inspired feel. It’s particularly effective in rooms that get plenty of natural light, as the nuances of the color really come to life in sunlight.
In essence, while both colors are rooted in gray, Pewter Tankard offers a warmer palette, whereas Western Reserve brings a deeper, earthier tone. The choice between them depends on the mood you’re aiming to achieve in your room.
You can see recommended paint color below:

In wrapping up my thoughts on SW 0023 Pewter Tankard by Sherwin Williams, I have found that this paint color is truly special. This shade of gray brings a calm feeling to any room without making it feel gloomy or too dark. It’s like the color of a cloudy sky, which can be soothing and gentle.
Using this color can make different rooms in a house look neat and polished. It works well whether you’re painting a busy kitchen or a quiet place for reading. What’s great is that it doesn’t clash with bright colors or furniture, making it easy to use wherever you want.
Additionally, because the color is simple and soft, it’s a good choice for people looking to sell their homes. Rooms painted in Pewter Tankard might appeal to buyers because the color makes the interior areas look clear, attractive, and ready to move into.
So, if you’re thinking about giving your walls a new coat of paint, SW 0023 Pewter Tankard is an excellent pick. It’s not just another shade of gray; it’s a color that provides a neat backdrop and goes well with just about everything. Whether you’re sprucing up a single room or the whole house, this color could be just what you need.

Ever wished paint sampling was as easy as sticking a sticker? Guess what? Now it is! Discover Samplize's unique Peel & Stick samples.
Get paint samples